NFT royalties have been a big topic of discussion for the last few months, with big players like OpenSea and Magic Eden changing their royalty models to try and take back market share from competitors that offer 0% royalties.
Creator royalties are a percentage (typically 5-10%) that goes to the original creators when an NFT is sold. Royalties are not enforceable at the smart-contract level so it has always been up to marketplaces to enforce this.
Magic Eden recently launched an Open Creator Protocol Tool to enforce royalties for new Solana projects, which works similar to OpenSea’s tool, giving creators the option to blacklist marketplaces that don’t enforce royalties.
However the issue still remains for existing collections left with the only option to “burn” and “re-mint” using the new protocol to then start enforcing royalties.
Dust Labs, a sister software company to the y00ts and DeGods NFT collection, today launched NFT Blue with the aim to show support for creator royalties. NFT Blue allows users of Solana to connect their wallets and download a star-shaped version of their NFT to use as their profile picture. Additionally, the app shows how much you’ve paid (in SOL) directly to creators through royalties.
NFT Blue & Creator Royalties were pretty sexy NGL pic.twitter.com/F4huCC5xXg
— Jaxx ❤️ (@0xJaxxx) December 7, 2022
FrankDeGods, creator of the DeGods and y00ts has been vocal on situation on Twitter, adding blame
to Magic Eden as well as NFT aggregator marketplace Hyperspace for supporting non-royalty enforced marketplaces.
I will be keeping the ⭐️ PFP until @MagicEden & @hyperspacexyz & the other Solana NFT marketplaces decide to bring back royalties.
— Frank (@frankdegods) December 7, 2022
Community responds
Whilst some see it as a good idea, others not so much…
Is Frank going to bring the royalties back? No
— ????ChartFuMonkey (97%) ???? (@ChartFuMonkey) December 8, 2022
Is a protocol-level solution going to do it? Yes
We can't count on social contracts, that's why people started using code because it's reliable, unlike people
I'm not trynna FUD degods but I don't understand protesting with a star profile picture after front running 0% royalties pic.twitter.com/mBPGUqH7iR
— Obey Raves ???? (@Ravers) December 8, 2022
Fact is @frankdegods time and again tries to help the space, and gets crucified by the people hes trying to help. You can continue to point fingers or listen to the point:
— Nineties (33.3%) (@NinetiesNFT) December 8, 2022
If we dont work together to restore royalties, we will lose some of our favorite projects. Not @DeGodsNFT.
. @frankdegods you said yesterday on our stream that our biggest downfall was calling out other platforms, and now it seems like you're the champion of livestreams and calling out other platforms. Are we writing the playbook for you too now
— bryan | hyperspace ???????? (@thebryanjun) December 8, 2022
Can't star flex, but I can star meme @frankdegods pic.twitter.com/D1SVawKOIg
— Shawn Humphreys (@shawnhumphreys) December 8, 2022